Racial Divide in Attitudes Towards the Police


The high-profile police killings of unarmed black people and the protests that followed generated a spate of public opinion research during 2014–16. The big takeaway is that although these events produced some movement among some white Americans towards a greater appreciation of the systemic racism in law enforcement, the black/Latino-white divide on attitudes towards the police remains deep and wide. There is also a wide gap based on political affiliation, with Democrats moving much further along than Republicans, with Independents in between.

Confidence in the police as an institution

In June 2015, Gallup released the data from its annual “confidence in U.S. institutions” poll which includes a question about the police. The article accompanying the poll results was headlined, “In U.S., Confidence in Police Lowest in 22 Years.” Fifty-two percent of the public had confidence in the police as compared to a high of 64 percent in 2004.56 But a closer look at the demographic breakdown reveals only a three-point drop in confidence among whites, from 60 percent in 2012–13 to 57 percent in 2014–15, compared to a seven-point drop among nonwhites, from 49 percent to 42 percent. The biggest drop in confidence was among Democrats: from 55 percent to 42 percent, a 13-point drop. Among Republicans, confidence actually went up by one point, from 68 to 69 percent. A YouGov/Huffington Post survey conducted in July 2015 showed that when asked, “Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion of police officers in your community?” 65 percent said “favorable” and 25 percent said “unfavorable” with the balance responding “unsure.” Again, the racial differences are extreme: 70 percent of whites said “favorable” compared to only 43 percent of blacks and 49 percent of Latinos. Fifty-seven percent of Democrats said “favorable” compared to 81 percent of Republicans.57

Whites and people of color report very different subjective responses to encounters with the police. Half of whites say they have “a great deal of confidence” in the police to gain the trust of those they serve compared with only 22 percent of blacks.58 Whites are much more likely than blacks or Latinos to say their experience with the police has been “mostly good.”

Colorful circles showing personal experiences with the police with demographic breakdown by percentage in each circle.

Figure 11. Source: YouGov/Huffington Post59

Colorful double bar graph that dynamically shows "yes" or "no" to warning their children to be careful when dealing with the police broken down by demographic.

Figure 12. Source: Ibid60

Do the police treat everyone equally?

People of color and whites have very different assessments of whether the police treat everyone equally:

Colorful chart showing percentages of opinion on how local police treats minorities based on demographic.

Figure 13. Source: MSNBC/Telemundo/Marist Poll61

Responses to the following question about “police in most cities” reflect both the racial and the partisan divide:

 

Thumbnail

 

Figure 14. Source: YouGov/Huffington Post62

White responses to a similar question posed by the Public Religion Research Institute at about the same time were somewhat different. Asked whether they or agreed or disagreed with the statement, “Police officers generally treat blacks and other minorities the same as whites,” 50 percent agreed, but 48 percent disagreed, suggesting that white Americans are evenly split on the question.63

Recent surveys of Latinos show disquiet about their treatment by the police. One out of three Latinos thinks they are “usually treated unfairly” by local police, border patrol, and other law enforcement authorities.64 And 20 percent of Latinos report that they have personally been treated unfairly by the police.65

Americans today are a bit more likely to believe that blacks are treated unfairly “in dealing with the police, such as traffic incidents” than they were a decade ago. In 2007, 37 percent thought so; by 2015 forty-three percent thought so.66 In response to the question, “In general do you think the police stop people of certain racial or ethnic groups because they believe that these groups are more likely than others to commit certain types of crimes, or don’t you think this happens?” 65 percent say it happens. But in response to another question in the same survey about the use of deadly force, a slight majority denies race plays a role:

“In general do you think that the police in most communities are more likely to use deadly force against a black person or more likely to use deadly force against a white person, or don’t you think race affects police use of deadly force?”

Forty percent believe the police are more likely to use deadly force against a black person, but 51 percent believe race does not matter. The racial divide is stark in responses to both of these questions. In the first instance regarding “police stops,” 61 percent of whites think racial profiling happens compared to 88 percent of blacks. In the second instance regarding use of deadly force, the comparable figures are 33 percent of whites compared to 84 percent of blacks.67

Police Accountability

Divisions based on race are also reflected in surveys that have probed attitudes towards police accountability. According to a CNN poll taken shortly before the announcement of the Missouri grand jury’s decision not to indict police officer Darren Wilson for the death of Michael Brown, 54 percent of nonwhites (blacks, Latinos, and Asians) said Wilson should be charged with murder, while just 23 percent of whites agreed.68 A December 2014 poll by CBS News probing reactions to both the decision of the Missouri grand jury and a Staten Island grand jury’s decision not to indict NYPD officer Daniel Pantaleo in the death of Eric Garner showed the same racial divide:

Moving pie charts depicting "pleased or satisfied," "don't know" or "disappointed or angry" feelings about the Michael Brown case by demographic.

Figure 15. Source: CBS News Poll69

Moving pie charts depicting "pleased or satisfied," "don't know" or "disappointed or angry" feelings about the Eric Garner case by demographic.

Figure 16. Source: CBS News Poll

A much higher percentage of people of color thought the federal government should bring civil rights charges against Darren Wilson than did whites. Seventy-five percent of blacks and 50 percent of Latinos thought it should, compared to 23 percent of whites.70 But in May 2015, a strong majority of 65 percent overall thought it was the “right decision” to bring criminal charges against Baltimore police officers for the death of Freddie Gray. Still, racial and partisan divisions persisted: 60 percent of whites compared to 78 percent of blacks thought it was the right decision, as did 75 percent of Democrats and only 45 percent or  Republicans.71

Black Lives Matter Movement

In response to the question, “From what you have heard or seen about Black Lives Matter, do you mostly agree or mostly disagree with Black Lives Matter, or don’t you have an opinion either way,” overall 34 percent say they mostly agree, 24 percent say they mostly disagree, and a relatively large percentage, 38 percent, say they don’t have an opinion.72 Blacks, Latinos, and whites differ in their assessments, with black Americans views much more positive than whites and Latinos. Thirty-one percent of both whites and Latinos say they “mostly agree” compared to 65 percent of blacks. The same percentage of whites and Latinos say they “mostly disagree” (27 percent) compared to only 5 percent of blacks. And approximately a third of all three groups say they don’t have an opinion either way.73

Some sense of the basis for white and Latino disapproval of Black Lives Matter is revealed in another question in the same survey. When asked to choose between the following two statements:

  • a) Black Lives Matter focuses attention on the real issues of racial discrimination
  • b) Black Lives Matter distracts attention from the real issues of racial discrimination

the same division appears, with 65 percent of blacks choosing (a) and 59 percent and 57 percent of whites and Latinos, respectively, choosing (b).74

Policing Reforms

Americans are more united when it comes to some of the policing reforms under public discussion. A 60 percent majority of Americans say they oppose racial profiling by the police and support a ban on the practice.75 Majorities of all groups (62 percent of whites, 71 percent of blacks, and 67 percent of Latinos) agree that “policies and system-wide training programs should be put in place to prevent” racial profiling.76 Large majorities of both blacks and whites (92 percent and 86 percent, respectively) support the use of outside prosecutors in cases of police killings of unarmed civilians. Eighty-eight percent and 87 percent of blacks and whites, respectively think the public should be allowed to videotape the police. And 93 percent of both blacks and whites favor requiring on-duty police officers to wear video cameras “which would record events and actions as they occur.”77

 

 

56 Jeffrey M. Jones, “In U.S., Confidence in Police Lowest in 22 Years,” Gallup, June 19, 2015.
57 YouGov/Huffington Post  survey,  July  23–27,  2015, https://today.yougov.com/news/2015/07/29/poll-results-police/.
58 McClatchy-Marist Poll, “Ferguson and Beyond: Race Permeates Views of Law Enforcement, December 15, 2014. http://maristpoll.marist.edu/1215- ferguson-and-beyond-race-permeates-views-of-law-enforcement/.
59 YouGov/Huffington Post op cit.
60 Ibid.
61 MSNBC/Telemundo/Marist Poll, “Immigration Reform and Race Relations, September 15, 2015, http://maristpoll.marist.edu/914-issues-2016-
immigration-reform-and-race-relations/. See also McClatchy-Marist Poll, “Ferguson and Beyond: Race Permeates Views of Law Enforcement,
December 15, 2014, http://maristpoll.marist.edu/1215-ferguson-and-beyond-race-permeates-views-of-law-enforcement/.
62 YouGov/Huffington Post, op cit.
63 Public Religion Research Institute, American Values survey 2015.
64 W.K. Kellogg Foundation, National Survey of Latino Households, September 19–October 15, 2014,
http://www.latinodecisions.com/files/3814/1582/4627/Topline_Results_WKKF_State_of_the_Latino_Family_2014.pdf.
65 Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Center for Health Policy, Latino National Health Survey, March 24, 2015, http://www.latinodecisions.com/files/1214/2707/3700/UNM_RWJF_Center_Toplines_Posted.pdf.
66 Gallup, “Americans’ Satisfaction with Way Blacks Treated Tumbles,” August 4, 2015, http://www.gallup.com/poll/184466/americans-satisfactionblacks-treated-tumbles.aspx.
67 CBS News Poll, December 2014, http://www.cbsnews.com/news/michael-brown-and-eric-garner-the-police-use-of-force-and-race/. Note that this poll was taken after Michael Brown and Eric Garner were killed, but before Freddie Gay and Tamir Rice were killed.
68 CNN, “Poll finds racial divide over Wilson charges,” November 24, 2014, http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/24/politics/ferguson-wilson-cnn-poll/.
69 CBS News Poll, “Michael Brown and Eric Garner: The police, use of force, and race,” December 10, 2014, http://www.cbsnews.com/news/michaelbrown-and-eric-garner-the-police-use-of-force-and-race/.
70 McClatchy-Marist Poll, op cit.
71 Pew Research Center, “Multiple Causes Seen for Baltimore Unrest,” May 4, 2015, http://www.people-press.org/2015/05/04/multiple-causes-seenfor-baltimore-unrest/.
72 PBS NewsHour/Marist Poll, “Race Relations in the United States,” September 2015.
73 Ibid. People between the ages of 18 and 29 and Democrats are more supportive than the general public, with 42 percent of young people and 51 percent of Democrats saying they mostly agree with Black Lives Matter.
74 Ibid.
75 The Leadership Conference Education Fund, “Poll Finds Strong Support for Strict Guidelines and Community Input for Body-Worn Cameras, for Banning Racial Profiling and for Reforming Civil Asset Forfeiture Laws,” October 2015.
76 The Opportunity Survey, The Opportunity Agenda and Langer Research Associates, February-March 2014.
77 Roper Center, “Black, White, and Blue: Americans’ Attitudes on Race and Police,” September 22, 2015, https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=Roper+Center%2C+%E2%80%9CBlack%2C+White%2C+and+Blue%3A+Americans%E2%80%99+Attitudes+on+Race+and+Police.